‘These are just a few examples of our daily oppressions’: Speaking and listening to homosexuality in Australia’s Royal Commission on Human Relationships, 1974-1977
Abstract
The Royal Commission on Human Relationships was an initiative of the Whitlam government, instigated in 1974 to investigate ‘the family, social, educational, legal and sexual aspects of male and female relationships’. The three commissioners (Justice Elizabeth Evatt, journalist Anne Deveson and Archbishop of Brisbane Felix Arnott) delivered their final report in 1977: that the report contained thirteen recommendations about homosexuality was testament to the success of gay and lesbian activists in placing their concerns on the Commission’s agenda. Through an examination of the testimonies and submissions presented by gay men and lesbians to the Royal Commission, this paper will investigate the ways that these activists framed their public, citizen identities as homosexuals, and how this framing found purchase in the Commission’s recommendations. Seeking rights and protections from a newly receptive Australian social liberal state, gay men and lesbians framed their experiences through narratives of exclusion, trauma and a nascent language of homosexual citizenship. This language drew upon the ways that women’s liberationists were framing their claims on the state and also shaped by the ways that that state was recognising these emergent political actors, such as women and migrants. By presenting themselves as unequal citizens, subject to ‘daily oppressions’, gays and lesbians worked to legitimize the homosexual sexual citizen and his or her claims on the state, even as it recast and reinforced the power of the state in the process.
References
Stephen Angelides, ‘”The Continuing Homosexual Offensive”: Sex education, gay rights and homosexual recruitment’, in Homophobia: An Australian History, ed. Shirleene Robinson (Annandale: Federation Press, 2008) 172-191.
Katharine Betts, ‘Attitudes to Abortion in Australia: 1972 to 2003’, People and Place, 12, no. 4 (2004) 22-28
David Broadbent, Stephen Nisbet and John Teerds, ‘Sex Report Shocks PM’, The Age, 1 December 1977, 3.
‘CAMP’s Submission to the Royal Commission on Human Relationships’, Camp Ink, 4, no. 4/5, 1975,14.
CAMP NSW, Homosexuals and Human Relationships, (Sydney: CAMP NSW, 1975).
Commonwealth Reporting Service, Royal Commission on Human Relationships: Official Transcript of Proceedings, 1976.
Peter de Waal papers, State Library of NSW, MLMSS 6089, Box 5.
Anne Deveson, Australians At Risk, (Stanmore: Cassell Australia,1978) 4.
Hester Eistenstein, Inside Agitators: Australian Femocrats and the State, (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1996);
Elizabeth Evatt, records of the Royal Commission on Human Relationships, National Archives of Australia (NAA), Series M3655/1, (henceforth Evatt papers), Box 27, Folder 285.
Elizabeth Evatt, Felix Arnott, Anne Deveson, Royal Commission on Human Relationships, Interim Report 1 (Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service, 1976) 6.
Elizabeth Evatt, Felix Arnott, Anne Deveson, Royal Commission on Human Relationships Final Report 5 vols. (Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service, 1977) 4:3; 1:124.
Elizabeth Evatt, in Ann Curthoys, A.W. Martin and Tim Rowse (eds) Australians From 1939, (Broadway: Fairfax, Syme and Weldon Associates,1987), 413.
Liz Fell and Carolyn Wenzel, The Coming Out Show: Twenty Years of Feminist ABC Radio, (Sydney, ABC Books, 1995).
Suzanne Franzway, Diane Court, R.W. Connell, Staking A Claim: Feminism, Bureaucracy and the State, (Sydney: Allen and Unwin, 1989).
Alan Gill, ‘Catholic Move to Stop CAMP evidence’, The Sydney Morning Herald, 20 November 1975, 3.
Carol Johnson, ‘Gough Whitlam and Labor Tradition’, in Troy Bramston (ed.) The Whitlam Legacy, (Sydney: Federation Press, 2013), 359.
Carol Johnson ‘From Morality to Equality: Labor’s Sexuality Conundrum’, paper presented at Australian Political Studies Association Annual Conference, August 29, 2014, http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2440135, 3.
‘”Morals” Report Uproar’, The Sun, 30 November 1977, 1.
‘Oppression: a case history’ Camp Ink, 5 no 1, 1975.
Clare Parker and Paul Sendziuk, 'It's Time: The Duncan Case and the decriminalisation of homosexual acts in South Australia, 1972’, in Smaal and Willett, Out Here:17-35.
Alan Reid ‘Commission recommends legal brothels, abortions for girls 14’, The Bulletin, 3 December 1977, 38-9.
Elizabeth Reid, papers, National Library of Australia (hereafter cited as NLA) MS9262, Series 16, Box 54.
Elizabeth Reid, ‘The Child of our Movement: A Movement of Women’, in Different Lives, Jocelynne A. Scutt ed. (Ringwood: Penguin,1987) 9-20.
Robert Reynolds, From Camp to Queer: Remaking the Australian Homosexual, (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 2002).
Joan Sangster, ‘Words of Experience/Experiencing Words: Reading Working Women’s letters to Canada’s Royal Commission on the Status of Women’, in her Through Feminist Eyes: Essays on Canadian Women’s History, (Edmonton AU Press ,2011).
Marian Sawer with Gail Radford, Making Women Count: A History of the Women’s Electoral Lobby, (Sydney: UNSW Press, 2008), 33.
Marian Sawer, Sisters in Suits: Women and Public Policy in Australia (Sydney: Allen and Unwin 1990)
Jeffrey Weeks, ‘The Sexual Citizen’, Theory, Culture and Society, 15 no.3, (1998):35-52.
Graham Willett, Living Out Loud: A History of Gay and Lesbian Activism in Australia, (Sydney: Allen and Unwin, 2000), 22.
Graham Willett, ‘’We Blew Our Trumpets and…’: The ATC Homosexual Law Reform Society, in Yorick Smaal and Graham Willett (eds) Out Here: Gay and Lesbian Perspectives VI, Monash University Publishing, Clayton, 2011, 1-16: 2.
Anna Yeatman, Bureaucrats, Technocrats, Femocrats: Essays on the Contemporary Australian State (Sydney: Allen and Unwin, 1990).
